Cheesesteak Tortellini in Creamy Provolone Sauce Recipe

Cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce is about to become your new weeknight obsession. Picture this: tender, pillowy cheese tortellini swimming in a silky provolone sauce, loaded with juicy shaved steak and perfectly caramelized peppers and onions. It’s basically a Philly cheesesteak that decided to take a luxurious trip to Italy, and honestly? Best decision ever.

I’m Rosie, and I’ve been making this cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce for years now. It started as a “what’s in my fridge” experiment on a random Tuesday, and it’s since become my family’s most-requested dinner. My husband literally does a happy dance when I tell him it’s on the menu (yes, really).

This isn’t just another pasta recipe. This is the kind of meal that makes you close your eyes on the first bite and wonder why you ever ordered takeout. And the best part? You can have this restaurant-quality dinner on the table in under 40 minutes.

Table of Contents

Why This Cheesesteak Tortellini in Creamy Provolone Sauce is the BEST

Look, I know you’ve probably seen other versions of this recipe floating around. But here’s why my cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce actually delivers:

Incredibly Rich Flavor: We’re not just dumping cheese into cream and calling it a day. This sauce has layers – garlic, beef broth, Worcestershire sauce, and perfectly melted provolone that coats every single tortellini like a creamy hug.

Ready in Under 40 Minutes: Because you deserve an indulgent meal even on busy weeknights. No fancy techniques, no all-day simmering required.

Simple, Accessible Ingredients: Everything you need is available at your regular grocery store. No hunting down specialty items or driving to three different stores.

Foolproof Instructions: I’ve tested this Cheesesteak Tortellini in Creamy Provolone Sauce more times than I can count (my family wasn’t complaining). Every step is designed to set you up for success, even if you’re not super confident in the kitchen.

The Key Ingredients That Make It Magic

For the Cheesesteak

The Steak: This is where it all begins for your cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce. Shaved ribeye is my number one choice – it’s got beautiful marbling that melts into buttery goodness when you sear it, If you’re new to cooking with shaved steak, USDA’s guide to beef cuts can help you understand different options.. If ribeye isn’t in the budget, thinly sliced sirloin works beautifully too. The key word here is thin. You want those delicate, melt-in-your-mouth pieces that char perfectly in a hot pan. Pro tip: Ask your butcher to shave it for you, or buy pre-shaved steak from the frozen section.

The Vegetables: Green bell peppers and yellow onions are the classic combo for a reason. When you cook them low and slow, they caramelize into sweet, jammy perfection that adds depth to every bite. Don’t rush this step – those golden-brown edges are where the flavor lives.

For the Creamy Provolone Sauce

The Cheese: Provolone is the absolute star of this Cheesesteak Tortellini in Creamy Provolone Sauce. It melts like a dream and has this slightly sharp, nutty flavor that’s bold enough to stand up to the beef without overpowering everything. The key is using good-quality provolone from the deli counter, not pre-sliced sandwich cheese, Check out The Spruce Eats’ guide to Italian cheeses to learn more about provolone varieties and their melting properties.. If you can’t find provolone, fontina is a fantastic alternative with a similar creamy texture.

The Cream Base: Heavy cream creates that luxurious, velvety texture we’re after in this tortellini recipe. But here’s where we get smart – we’re adding minced garlic for aromatics, beef broth to enhance the meaty flavors, and a splash of Worcestershire sauce for that savory umami kick that makes you go “wait, what IS that amazing flavor?”

The Pasta

Cheese Tortellini: Fresh, refrigerated tortellini is what you want here. It cooks in just 3-4 minutes and has this tender, pillowy texture that dried pasta just can’t match. Plus, there’s cheese inside the tortellini and cheese in the sauce. That’s just smart layering, friends.

How to Make Cheesesteak Tortellini in Creamy Provolone Sauce (Step-by-Step)

Making this cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce is easier than you think. Let me walk you through it.

Step 1: Cook the Tortellini

Bring a large pot of salted water to a rolling boil. Add your tortellini and cook according to the package directions (usually just 3-4 minutes for fresh). Drain and set aside. Here’s a trick: don’t rinse them. That starchy coating helps the sauce cling better.

Step 2: Sear the Steak

Heat a large skillet over medium-high heat with a drizzle of oil. Once it’s smoking hot, add your shaved steak in a single layer. This is crucial: don’t touch it for about 2 minutes. I know it’s tempting to poke and prod, but resist! Letting it sit creates that gorgeous brown crust (that’s the Maillard reaction doing its thing), want to geek out on the science? Serious Eats explains the Maillard reaction in detail.. Season with salt and pepper, flip, cook another minute, then remove to a plate. Don’t overcrowd the pan – work in batches if needed.

Step 3: Sauté the Vegetables

In the same pan (all those browned bits are flavor gold), add a bit more oil if needed. Toss in your sliced onions and bell peppers. Cook over medium heat for about 8-10 minutes, stirring occasionally, until they’re soft and starting to get those caramelized edges. This is where patience pays off for your Cheesesteak Tortellini in Creamy Provolone Sauce.

Step 4: Build the Provolone Sauce

Push your veggies to the side and add minced garlic to the center of the pan. Cook for about 30 seconds until fragrant (but not brown – burnt garlic is bitter). Now pour in your beef broth and Worcestershire sauce, scraping up all those delicious browned bits from the bottom of the pan. Let it simmer for a minute, then reduce heat to low and stir in the heavy cream.

Step 5: Melt the Cheese

This is where the magic happens in your cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce. Remove your pan from direct heat or keep it on the absolute lowest setting. Add your shredded provolone a handful at a time, stirring constantly until it’s completely melted before adding more. Low and slow is the name of the game here – high heat will cause your sauce to break and get grainy (nobody wants that).

Step 6: Combine Everything

Gently fold your cooked tortellini and seared steak into that gorgeous creamy provolone sauce. Toss everything together until each tortellini is coated in that silky goodness. Taste and adjust your seasoning if needed. Serve your cheesesteak tortellini immediately, maybe with some fresh parsley or extra provolone on top if you’re feeling extra.

Pro-Tips for Recipe Success

Want to make the absolute best cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce? These tips will help you nail it every single time.

Tip 1: Don’t Move the Steak – I mentioned this before, but it’s worth repeating. When you leave the meat alone in that hot pan, you get a beautiful sear that adds incredible flavor to your cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce. If you’re constantly stirring and flipping, you’ll just steam it instead.

Tip 2: Shred Your Own Cheese – I know it’s more work, but trust me on this. Pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking agents that prevent it from melting smoothly. You’ll end up with a grainy, separated sauce. Buy a block and grate it yourself – it takes two minutes and makes all the difference in your tortellini recipe.

Tip 3: The Secret to a Silky Sauce – Use room-temperature heavy cream (take it out of the fridge 20 minutes before cooking) and add your cheese slowly over low heat. If your sauce does break, whisk in a tablespoon of cream to bring it back together.

Tip 4: Don’t Overcook the Tortellini – Remember, it’s going to sit in hot sauce for a few minutes, so it’ll continue cooking slightly. Slightly al dente is perfect for this cheesesteak tortellini recipe.

Variations and Substitutions

One of the best things about cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce is how adaptable it is. Here are some fun ways to make it your own:

Make it Spicy: Add a pinch of red pepper flakes to the sauce or sauté some sliced jalapeños with your peppers and onions. My son likes to drizzle hot sauce on his at the table.

Add Mushrooms: Sliced baby bellas sautéed with the peppers and onions add an extra layer of earthy, umami goodness that takes this tortellini recipe over the top.

Different Cheeses: For that authentic cheesesteak flavor in your cheesesteak tortellini, try a mix of provolone and American cheese. The American melts incredibly smoothly and adds that nostalgic cheesesteak taste.

Make it Gluten-Free: Use your favorite gluten-free pasta instead of tortellini. You’ll lose the cheese-filled center, but the sauce is so good it’ll still be amazing.

Serving and Storing Your Cheesesteak Tortellini

What to Serve With: Keep it simple so this cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce can shine. A crisp green salad with a tangy vinaigrette cuts through the richness beautifully, Need salad inspiration? Bon Appétit has excellent vinaigrette recipes that pair perfectly with rich pasta dishes.. Garlic bread for sopping up extra sauce is never a bad call, or roasted broccoli if you want some green on your plate.

How to Store Leftovers: Transfer your leftover cheesesteak tortellini to an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 3 days. The creamy provolone sauce will thicken as it cools (it happens with all cream sauces).

Reheating Instructions: Reheat gently on the stovetop over low heat, adding a splash of milk or cream to loosen the sauce back up. This keeps your cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce just as delicious as when you first made it.

There you have it – the ultimate cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce that’s going to become your new weeknight hero. It’s indulgent enough to feel special but easy enough to make on a random Tuesday when you just need something delicious in your life.

Give this cheesesteak tortellini recipe a try and let me know how it turns out! Drop a comment below and rate the recipe – I read every single one, and your feedback helps other home cooks find recipes they’ll love. And if you’re feeling it? Take a picture and tag me on social media. I live for seeing your kitchen creations!

Now go forth and make the best dang cheesesteak tortellini in creamy provolone sauce of your life. You’ve got this! 🧀

Frequently Asked Questions